Abstract PPP （Public-Private Partnership） mode has seen an increasingly wide application. However， not all projects are suitable for PPP mode and there is an abuse of it. In order to assess the suitability of PPP， this paper proposes the GOD （Goods-Operation-Delivery） analysis method which simplifies its assessment into three steps and three criteria. Firstly， project output attributes are analyzed to identify projects that do not need to adopt PPP mode based on public goods theory. Secondly， project operation attributes are analyzed to identify projects that cannot adopt PPP mode based on the public power theory. Finally， the delivery efficiency of projects is analyzed to determine whether it should give priority to PPP mode based on the concept of comparative advantage. To demonstrate the application of the GOD analysis method， this paper presents a demonstrative analysis of suitability of PPP mode for smart city construction programme. The results show that the GOD analysis method can be used to assess PPP suitability of projects quite well.
YE Su-dong,YANG Jia-qin. GOD Analysis of PPP Suitability for Projects ——A Case Study of Smart City Construction Programme[J]. journal6, 2023, 22(2): 117-124.
1 HM Treasury. PFI Value for Money Quantitative Assessment ［M］. London： the Stationery Office， 2006. 2 Federal Highway Administration. Value for Money Assessment for Public-Private Partnerships: A Primer [M]. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Transportation, 2012. 3 Infrastructure Australia. National PPP Guidelines Volume 2: Practitioner’s Guide [M]. Melbourne: Infrastructure Australia, 2008. 4 PPP Canada. New Building Canada Fund: Procurement Options Analysis Guide [M]. Ottawa: PPP Canada, 2014. 5 Public Private Infrastructure Investment Management Center. Detailed Guideline for Value-for-Money Test for Build-Transfer-Operate (BTO) and Public-Private Partnership (PPP) Projects [M]. Seoul: Korea Development Institute, 2010. 6 财政部. 关于印发《PPP物有所值评价指引（试行）》的通知（财金[2015]167号）[A/OL]. (2015-12-18) [2021-01-05]. http://www.mof.gov.cn/gp/xxgkml/jrs/201512/t20151229_2512409.htm. 7 ISO. Sustainable Cities and Communities — Indicators for Smart Cities: ISO 37122:2019(E) [S]. 2019.
2023, Vol. 22 
